LINUX BLOG SAFARI

In Search of Linux’s Greatest Moment

There’s no denying that Linux has had a lot of great moments since the turn of the millennium, and Linux Girl has done her best to highlight each and every one of them here on LinuxInsider’s pages — at least over the past six or so of those years.

Recently, however, the always-engaging crew over at TuxRadar came up with an interesting question: “We thought we’d ask you what you think has been the greatest moment for Linux since the start of the millennium.

“Perhaps it was 20 October 2008 when Ubuntu became Linux for human beings, or was it October 2011 when Android (possibly) took over 50 percent of the smartphone market share,” the team suggested. “Was it when Raspberry Pi introduced cheap and cheerful Linux computers to an excited world, or when SCO filled for bankruptcy in September 2007?”

That question is now the basis for one of the site’s ever-popular Open Ballot polls, and it’s had tongues wagging ever since — both in the comments section and throughout the blogosphere at large.’Windows Can’t Do This!’Linux Girl

“For me it was 20 October 2008 when Ubuntu became Linux for human beings,” offered Govannon in the TuxRadar comments, for example.

“For me personally it was the day I stopped dual-booting and wiped my Windows installation with Mandrake 10 because I decided the system was solid and broad enough to cover all my computing needs,” said Morten Juhl-Johansen Zlde-Fejr.

Alternatively, “it’s the private moment you have at home, playing with a fresh install, and you find that *one* application, and you think, ‘Windows can’t do this!'” suggested merelyjim.

Geeks down at the blogosphere’s Punchy Penguin Saloon had plenty of their own ideas.’Truly a Watershed Moment'”The moment a Linux install became easier than a Windows install,” opined consultant and Slashdot blogger Gerhard Mack, for example.

“September 23, 2008, when T-Mobile announced the very first Android powered phone, the G1,” offered Linux Rants blogger Mike Stone.

“It was a rise to power — the first in a long line of releases that would put Linux literally in the hands of millions of people in the general public,” Stone explained.

“It would be the first event of many that would lead to Linux eventually overtaking Microsoft and Apple in the computing device market by a wide margin, and inspiring a wide range of other Linux based devices in dozens of different categories,” he added. “In my opinion, it was truly a watershed moment.”

‘The Day Android Was Released’

Slashdot blogger hairyfeet saw it similarly.

“The day Android was released,” hairyfeet agreed. “That was the day Linux was taken out of the hands of a bazillion little fiefdoms filled with maintainers that never talk to each other or work together, and instead FINALLY had someone come in and lay down the law and say, ‘It WILL be thus.’

“And what do ya know? Just as I said would happen if somebody would come along and bring real order to the chaos, Android has done in just a few years what Linux hasn’t been able to do in over 20: actually put real numbers on the board,” hairyfeet said.

It remains to be seen “if Google turns out to be just as nasty as MSFT — looking at how locked down the Chromebooks are, I’m starting to feel like it’s MSFT all over again,” he added.

Still, “one would be hard pressed to argue that Android wasn’t the REAL tipping point when it came to mainstream acceptance,” he opined. “Does anybody think Valve would be making a Linux client if all those Android games didn’t exist already, thus giving them ready games on tap?

“No question in my mind; the day Android was released trumps them all,” hairyfeet concluded.

‘The NYSE Migration’

Robin Lim, a lawyer and blogger on Mobile Raptor, had a different view.

“A year ago I would have said the coming of Android, but I don’t think the Linux Community in general considers Android as ‘Linux,'” Lim told Linux Girl. “Looking at the reaction to Ubuntu’s upcoming phone operating system, it looks like the Linux Community is still looking for a ‘true’ Linux smartphone operating system.”

Ubuntu, of course, “is an excellent Linux distribution, among many fine examples,” he added.

In any case, “the most significant moment of the millennium is not too hard to identify: the NYSE migration to Linux in 2008,” Lim asserted.

’50 Percent Plus One’

“I think that in terms of quantity and quality, two moments are the higher milestones for me,” Google+ blogger Gonzalo Velasco C. told Linux Girl.

First, “Red Hat becoming a billion dollar open source software company,” he explained. Second, “the moment of turning ’50 percent plus one’ with Android/Linux.”

Other notable contenders, however, include “the first GNU/Linux with graphic installation; Ubuntu becoming the most used GNU/Linux distribution and reaching newcomers; the development of Android, a Linux for phones; the creation of the first Raspberry Pi; and the moments when many governments decide to go Open Source Free/Libre Software.”

‘I Really Didn’t Need Windows’

There isn’t a single moment that stands out for Google+ blogger Kevin O’Brien, he confessed.

“At some point I discovered that I could actually use Linux (Mandrake at that time), and at another point I found I was spending more time in Linux than Windows, and then at some point I discovered that I really didn’t need Windows any longer,” O’Brien explained.

“But for me it has been a gradual movement,” he added.

‘Wintel Is Stagnant’

Last but not least, blogger Robert Pogson had yet another view.

“The most important moment for GNU/Linux in the 21st century probably was ASUS’s release of a netbook that sold out globally, delivering GNU/Linux to the masses for the first time,” he told Linux Girl. “After that, no one could convince the world that GNU/Linux is inferior or doesn’t do the job — too many millions of real people had felt the performance.”

After that, “M$ had to pay OEMs to install XP to stem the tide,” Pogson added.

Of course, “they could not do that when Android/Linux came along because the OEMs involved were not beholden to M$ and the cost of entry was too low for M$ to compete,” he pointed out. “Now most OEMs are shipping GNU/Linux on all kinds of notebooks and desktops and Wintel is stagnant in a growing market.”

Katherine Noyes has been writing from behind Linux Girl's cape since late 2007, but she knows how to be a reporter in real life, too. She's particularly interested in space, science, open source software and geeky things in general. You can also find her on Twitter and Google+.

3 Comments

  • There is no denying about the success, the HUGE success of Linux as a server or appliance OS.
    But, I am sorry, looking for the "greatest moment" as to Linux on the desktop seems to me still a far away dream.
    I am not objecting the success stories reported here, of course. But I have still to see someone who is not a geek and who decides to take a Linux desktop instead of a Mac (supposing they are sold at the same price).
    And the "core" of a Mac is so similar to the core of Linux…..

  • Robert Pogson gets the Grand Prize!
    All the others are indeed great answers in their own right…but Robert nailed it, in my opinion("You are entitled to your own opinion, but not to your own facts"). The EeePCs two most important contributions to the globe–and the world responded with a roar of approval–was the first mass-produced Linux computer with all it needed for instant approval, e.g., worked right out of the box, rugged, bright screen, and an intuitive OS which anyone could use immediately; secondly, it forced Microsoft to REALLY show its rear end. I’m convinced (my opinion) that this negative attribute of the EeePC’s introduction is a big part of Linux’s acceptance. That, and the very good job and very hard work being done by some–such as Clement Lefebvre and Mint Linux–who not only care about their own community, but give a lot back to the entire Linux community.
    Just one persons opinion(s).

    • Oh please! You DO know you are cheering a guy that is so whacked out he honestly has Voldemort syndrome, yes? look up his posts, or his blog, never in more than six bloody years has he EVER written Microsoft, MSFT, or even MS, its "The other OS" or "M$" like there is a MSFT ninja under his bed just waiting to force him to use Windows 8. The guy is nuttier than a fruitcake.

      And as for the EEE PC? you mean that DEAD PRODUCT that was canceled more than 6 months ago and which quit selling a Linux variant 6 months after it was released, THAT EEE PC? The one that was selling a PROPRIETARY version of Linux in Xandros who FYI ended up going bankrupt and closing their doors in 2009?

      On the netbooks we had Xandros (defunct) Linpus (defunct) and even those were canceled not 6 months after they were released because any retailer will tell you Linux distros are a mess, every update breaks more than it fixes and every release worse than the last.I have seen it with my own two peepers, we tried selling bog standard systems with ubuntu and had to stop because ubuntu fall down and go BOOM! on update.

      Now you can blame it on the devs throwing out working code for slpha quality garbage (KDE 4 and gnomeShell anyone? Or how about Pulse which is still a crashy mess?) or blame the fact that the world won’t embrace the crazy, whatever, but there is a REASON why 20 years of giving it away and Linux went nowhere, its because there are too many hassles for not enough reward.

      Mark my words, Windows 8 is complete and total garbage but even with MSFT putting out such a piece of junk Linux will gain NO share. Now Google’s proprietary versions called Android and ChromeOS might gain some share, but they are GPL V2 ONLY and compleetely controlled by Google who can lock them up at any time and several carriers already do, so if you count that as "freedom" you might as well just buy a MacBook.

      But until the Linux devs care more about users than their own egos and itch scratching Linux will never gain squat, netbooks were practically built for Linux and they bombed, every FOSS tablet and phone has bombed, heck even Dell had to pay an entire team to keep their own fork of Ubuntu, at no small expense i might add, because you couldn’t even use standard Ubuntu on machines built by Dell FOR Ubuntu, why? Well because the drivers break on update silly!

      So if you want to break your arm patting yourself on the back for a flop product? Go right ahead. MSFT decides they want to be a "premium brand" like Apple and kills Windows on netbooks what happened? The last netbook rolled off the line 3 months ago. If your theory was correct they would have just switched back to Linux, they didn’t did they? I rest my case.

Leave a Comment

Please sign in to post or reply to a comment. New users create a free account.

More by Katherine Noyes
More in Community

Which cybersecurity hazard do you fear the most as an individual?
Loading ... Loading ...

LinuxInsider Channels